We made an executive decision last weekend to take up the old plywood. It would end up costing us some more money, because we'd be buying brand new plywood, but the amount of time it would save alone makes it completely worth it. Plus we got a thinner plywood, so the top of the new finished floor will be level with the hearth and Dining Room floor.
We made it our goal to get at least half of the kitchen done today. It was mostly R tearing up the plywood (which was nailed every 2"!), but I would start each piece off, removing any screws and taking up the first couple nails. By the end of the day, we reached our goal and got all of the plywood out on the fireplace side of the kitchen. And we went and bought all the new plywood. We didn't find too many strange things, except that the floor we've been walking on in our hall is actually the kitchen's sub-floor, the plywood went underneath the "wall" separating the kitchen and hall (it's basically just a piece of drywall screwed into some wood paneling... no structural support at all.. about 1 1/2" thick), and that the floor wasn't in as bad shape as we originally thought. It's still not good enough for us to use as a finished floor, but it's not as unsafe as we thought. We've been walking on it for almost a week now and it's supporting us just fine!
Wow, that sub-flooring looks like wide-plank oak to me. It was the go-to flooring choice in 18th century Connecticut houses - I have it in mine. You would be amazed how well it can clean up with a little work. Even just an intense scrubbing can make it look great. If you like a more formal look, it can be sanded and oiled. Just something to think about before you put down more plywood.
ReplyDeleteTrust me, if we could keep this floor, we would. Unfortunately it's very spongy. When you walk on it it moves... a lot! Plus a lot of it is cracked and damaged. The rest of our house has the same flooring (though with different finishes) and they're all in good shape. I think that some day we'll go back to this floor and get it repaired (maybe supported from underneath?) and refinished.
ReplyDelete